Csci8380 (fall 2013): Paper Review Form Reviewer Name: Ting Xiao Paper Name: Enrichment and Ranking of the Youtube Tag Space and Integration with the Linked Data Cloud Section I. Overview A. Reader Interest

1. Which category describes this manuscript? _X_Practice/Application/Case Study/Experience Report ___Research/Technology ___Survey/Tutorial/How-To B. Content 1. Please explain how this manuscript advances this field of research and/or contributes something new to the literature. The authors of the paper has found the use-generated tags sometimes are too meaningless to be used by current retrieve techniques, so they design a framework using Semantic Web technologies to enrich, ranking and integration of web video tags. Since the research field is only concentrated on video media, the paper first introduces and analyzes the present study of tagging. According to these main disadvantages of current techniques of tag suggestion, ranking, they designed a new framework to expand the user-generated tag space, to rank and interlink the tags to DBpedia concepts for greater integration with other datasets. The result of the experiment shows after using the new framework, tag space become more sufficient. With the help of semantic web, tags are more meaningful, the retrieval and categorization of video is also improved as a result. 1. Does the introduction state the objectives of the manuscript in terms that encourage the reader to read on? _X_Yes ___Could be improved ___No 2. How would you rate the organization of the manuscript? Is it focused? Is the length appropriate for the topic? _X_Satisfactory ___Could be improved ___Poor